I'd forgotten about that scene! Yeah, wasn't my favorite either. Tell her that was sort af an aberration, the rest so far doesn't have that type of thing. My daughter has been reading the books and she is very happy with how they have been adapted. She's pretty picky about that, but she thinks in general they have followed the books well, and where they have made changes she thinks they are for the better, or at least don't detract from the story and characters.